When I was pregnant with Gee, before I had any actual children in my possession, I read The Absorbent Mind by Maria Montessori. It talks about the brain a lot, which was complicated and fascinating and largely escaped me, and also outlines the foundations for Maria's philosophies of raising and teaching children.
One part of the book astounded me from the very first. It detailed Maria's idea that children should never be contained. They should be free always to roam, explore, learn, experience their environment. Always. Even at night. Maria didn't believe in cribs. She postulated that babies, even newborn babies, didn't need them. They ought to be free, they could find the boundaries of a low mattress at just days old, they preferred to move at will.
I was intrigued, as I gazed at my pretty crib and my designer crib set, bought at Land of Nod for the mere cost of one of my arms, not to mention the drive to Seattle (four hours), night in a hotel (not cheap) and bagels and lox at the Fish Market (overpriced). I HAD to have the crib set from Land of Nod, which has stores only where rich people live and not in podunk, backwater towns eeking out a meager existence on the border of Idaho. On the Idaho border, we should be using cheap Target crib sets, bought used at the baby consignment sale, thank you very much.
Yeah, well, now I do use cheap, used sets because (big secret revealed here, if you don't have kids and don't want a spoiler, cover your eyes), KIDS PUKE AND PEE AND SHIT ALL OVER THE DAMN THINGS.
What can I say? Forgive me. I was very pregnant with my first precious baby and I'd lost a baby before that. Mind not working properly. Some things must be learned by experience.
Maria's little theory intrigued me. No cribs? Days-old babies can find the edge of a low mattress? Children should be free to roam and explore? Interesting.
Then, I had a baby and he came home and - SECOND SPOILER - he didn't sleep for two months unless his lips were firmly attached to my nipple or he was passed out cold face down on his father's chest. Or strapped into a car seat. Which, at two months gave his tired father and I an idea. What if we just put him on a low mattress and watched while he explored his environment and found the edge?
AHAHAHAHAHA. Funny girl, that Maria. No. We noodled his penchant for sleeping in a car seat a bit and said to each other. Us...what if we put the car seat INTO the crib. With him strapped in it. Asleep. And we did and he slept for eight hours, completely restrained like a teeny tiny resident of an insane asylum. Better him than me. It was a little bitty baby miracle.
And so our first beautiful baby slept buckled into a car seat in his crib - in eight hour stretches - for six months when our pediatrician kind of freaked out just a little bit and told us that we needed to try and transition him to a crib! !!
Duh. Panic unnecessary. By then I was all relaxed and experienced and I was like -
um, I don't think we're going to have to take the car seat to college and put it on his bunk. No. I was still very intimidated by pediatricians and words like developmental delay and permanent back damage. We switched him to a regular old crib. We didn't even consider a low mattress on the floor.
Want to know why, Maria? Yeah, you know you neglected to mention some things. THIRD SPOILER ALERT. Because babies MOVE. AROUND. Not just on the mattress. When they fall off of things they wake up and cry. They also have the brain capacity of a dim Labrador puppy. They chew on things. They pull things. Their entire existence revolves around wreaking as much havoc and mayhem as possible. How is the parent supposed to get any actual sleep with all of that roaming and exploration going on? Right.
My conclusion? Cribs are genius, obviously. They are little baby cages. Like a crate, for a puppy, except you cannot, under any circumstances, with the possible exception of a quick crying jag on the front porch, put the baby in his crate and leave. It's unfortunate, but true.
Nearly four years later, I own three cages, for my three puppies, I mean babies, for maximum restraint and containment and until last weekend, they all still slept in them.**
That's right, Maria. My three-year-and-eight-month-old children STILL slept in their cribs. Put that on you bruschetta and crunch it.
Until last weekend, that is, when we finally caved and converted Gee's crib to a toddler bed. No nod to Maria, it simply became marginally more of a pain in my ass for him to be in the crib than out of it. The whole "now-that-I-am-not-in-diapers-which-I-kept-completely-dry-for-ten-hours-for-over-a-year-I-must-get-up-and-pee-at-least-twice-a-night" thing.
The crib to toddler bed process:*



My favorite thing about their room, the photo border:

I cried a little. Not the quiet
oh my babies are growing up kind of cry. Let's face it, my kids probably should have been out of cribs a year ago. More of an oh-my-god-he-has-access-to-my-entire-house-while-I-sleep kind of cry. The roaming. The exploration. God help me.
Actually, we are eight nights in and he's been pretty good overall. He gets up about twice a night. He goes to the bathroom. He pees. He gets his PJs back on. He turns off the light and walks to the door of our room. Then, he whines and cries and whinges and tantrums until I agree to get up and 'put his covers back on.'
The end result is that I still have to get up every damn time he does, but it's massively more annoying because it's so unnecessary AND I've lost the crib containment. But, he's roaming and exploring! Finally. Maria would be so proud.***
*Yes, Ess is still in her crib. She doesn't wake during the night at all, still wears a pull up and might until she goes to college with her crib and her carseat. They are in the same room. This keeps them from roaming over to kill each other while I attempt to sleep.
**No, my kids have never climbed out of their cribs, ever, ever. It's not that they are non-explorative kids or because I am a good parent. It's because I am mean. I kid you not. Gee threw a leg over the side once when he was about 27 months and I had an epileptic fit on the floor and foamed at the mouth before I gave him a time out. He never tried it again. Roaming and exploration in the middle of the night are completely overrated.
***My editor and biggest critic, aka Matt, commented that this post might offend some people because, clearly, many, many people believe in the Montessori methods, especially for school. I've never visited a school, but I hear wonderful things. I'm absolutely not judging parents who are able to implement the roaming and exploration philosophy of child raising. I admire them. It's not my fault that my intense, type-A, lawyerish personality didn't magically disappear when I gave birth. Roaming makes me hyperventilate. So do markers.