Saturday, December 12, 2009

Matching

"Almost all the kids match," Gee declared.

I tensed a little in my miniature chair, wrapped both hands more tightly around my chai and waited to see if he would pursue it. Fourteen munchkins arrayed around the preschool snack table gave him varying levels of non-attention, fixated mostly on their little hoards of raisins and wheat crackers.

Vaguely, it occurred to me that "almost all" was a complicated concept. Their brains develop so fast. They inhale sophistication. I can watch their thinking process grow and change like bread rising.

"Almost all the kids are peach momma. We match. And Ess matches Teacher Miscilla."

Ess barked, a second after I predict it in my mind, "I match mommy's eyes."

This is a recurrent theme in our house for the last month or two. As their minds become aware of color. Of features. Of alike and not alike. Their brains breathe in, breathe out, puzzling it. Our skin is different. Our eyes are the same. Ess has a tummy mommy. I do not.

I'm torn by her desire to match me. We have worked so hard for three long years to attach as a family. My emotional identity as her mother is strong, but they are young, simple, physical beings still. She wants the hard evidence. She wants to belong to me in fibers and colors and names and skin. Words are not satisfactory. Love. Bond. Concepts can't be touched. They want to see and hold. Gee's hair matches Daddy's hair. Ess' eyes match Mommy's eyes.

I encourage it gently and hide my reservations. My fears are adult fears. I know that she needs an identity as she grows that includes her Haitian heritage and her brown skin. I know that someday soon a desire to match her white mother and not her African American teacher could mean that I have failed to combat the pervasive message in our society that white is beautiful. That princesses are blond. That different is bad.

Not yet though. I feel fairly confident of that. She tells me she is pretty. She smiles when I do her hair and asks if she can see it. Oh, she primps, it's beautiful. This four-year-old year, I see only a child exploring the ways she belongs in her family, not a child rejecting the way she looks.

The preschoolers looked to me, sticky handfuls of raisins half way to their mouths.

"I don't match," I reminded Gee, "my skin is olive. Ess' eyes match mine but her skin is chocolate like Teacher Priscilla. We are all unique. Who else has brown eyes?"

Four small hands went up. "I have blue eyes," an adorable little blond piped.

"You do. Who else has blue eyes?" More comparing. Liam has green eyes like Gee.

"But you're the only one with red hair," I told Gee, "we're all different and we all match."

Just as suddenly as it began, it's over. Their fickle attention shifted to something else, a spilled water cup, their dwindling raisins. Teacher Marietta directed them to the Rainbow Room where Ryan's Grandpa, an entomologist, is ready to show them his Australian leaf bugs. They are huge! They are interesting! The biggest one laid an egg on his hand! We talk about bugs and only bugs for days, but I know it will come back up. I know it's on their minds because of the way it surfaces and sinks and resurfaces in our conversations. Matching. Our skin. Our eyes.

This round is easy because they are easily satisfied. The hard questions wait for us around the corner.

I want to pour my heart into her. You are stunning. You are gorgeous. You are unique. Don't cave to them, with their airbrushes and their chemical treatments and their make believe women in their make believe lives. Don't think that pretty and picture perfect are equal. Don't think that there is a look, a hair color, a weight, a wardrobe that brings happiness. Happiness is a family that loves you. Happiness is friends to giggle with you all night. Happiness is wine night every Thursday. It's finding a passion. It's tracing 1000 year old carvings with your finger. It is pouring your heart into something and coming in second. It's in a hug. It is seeing your grandmother's eyes light up when she meets your baby boy.

It is inconstant. It takes effort.

If you try to bleach or tan or sleep or puke or buy or exercise or read or drug your way to it, it will always elude you.

She is too small. I know. She is too small for all these words. So, I put them here for her for someday. You can not know the weight of someone's heart by looking at them, darling. There are plenty of tiny blonds that cry themselves to sleep at night. There are redheads the world over that starve themselves in the name of a warped concept of beauty.

We are all different. We are all the same.

56 comments:

Amelia said...

Tears and goosebumps. Thank you for such lovely gifts.

heytheredearheart said...

Thank you for this post, Stace. And a special thanks on behalf of my own little princesses and prince.

Gayle said...

Very well written.

It's funny the things kids notice. Olivia will be five tomorrow and has never ever mentioned differences in skin color. She notices eyes and hair, but when her brother's black, mexican and native friends come over she's doesn't notice. Sadly, I'm sure that will come up once she goes to school, but for now she just doesn't see it.


Oh, and this should make you giggle. Olivia is also obsessed with the scale. Weighs herself every morning and every night. To be a thin five year old? No. She's gets very excited if it has a bigger number because it means she is growing. How cute is that?!

Ramit said...

I respect you more now. Much more. You're doing what I can only hope and dream to do. God bless you.

Shell said...

Beautifully stated.

Sheila said...

Once again, your writing has made me cry, think and wonder at your insights.

just making my way said...

So wonderfully written, Stacey. Just beautiful.

Mama Cas said...

Wow. My heart stopped when I read your first line...as if I knew immediately what the post would be about. I'm sure it's going to be a bumpy road for her and you, but you'll both be stronger and smarter for having traveled it.

KelleyO said...

Thank you I really needed this.

K.Line said...

Yet another layer of interesting parenting in your household! You do an excellent job of navigating it now - and I know you will continue to do so. And truly, Ess will feel beautiful because she has been taught to know that she is beautiful. The pendulum will swing and she'll be glad of her "difference" at times. This Xmas, the American Doll M requested is Sonali (South Asian); they couldn't look more different but it makes no difference to her...

K.Line said...

Could I have used the word "different" more times in that post :-)

kbreints said...

Wow. What an amazing gift of words and feelings and love for your daughter to read some day.

rachel... said...

I can only imagine how hard this must be. As a mom of four who, in a general sense, "match" quite well, there are still so many comparisons and insecurities (among themselves and with other children, too) that become more obvious as they get older. I notice it especially with my oldest daughter, and I'm not sure if it's age or gender...

I hope I'm dealing with it as well as you.

Molly said...

This is beautifully written. It sounds like you've done an awesome job with all of this. It'll be a process, like you know, but I wish it was so easy to pour our thoughts into them. I wish there was an easy way to remind people of how beautiful they are!

I have a little girl who introduces me as her sister. and she means it. She once told me she wished she had skin like me so she could be my sister, and I promise her that we were sisters regardless of skin color. We didnt have to match to be sisters. and from that day forward she introduced me as her sister. People always looked at me funny, but I just smiled back at them. She's in middle school now, so I don't see her as much, but she'll always be my sister!

Manic Mommy said...

Gremlin is the boy who will always need more attention, regardless of how much he gets. He's constantly comparing himself to his older brother.

Ess has one up on all her brothers; She is her parents' only daughter.

Different also means unique. And special.

Anne said...

There are 'differences' all around us and we struggle in our house to navigate the world with 3 girls who 'match' visually ~ but our middle daughter is extremely learning disabled. We rejoiced when she learned to ride a bike at a younger age than either of her 'normal' sisters. I can't count how many times we've hung her hat on that one. Just this week my oldest brought home straight A's from her first middle school report card. I instinctively wanted to 'create' a special prize for her accomplishment (like my parents had done $ for grades) ~ when I took pause and realized I would need to approach my own girls much differently. I couldn't set up a 'system' that one child would never be able to succeed at...

It is great that you have your brain working to wrap itself around the bumps that may come... gotta love that type A... it's is all the surprise bumps I may not guess that scare the crap out of me.

Mommy Mo said...

Love. this. post.

Anna See said...

Wow. Mine's only 8, and she "matches" me, but I still worry about when the world is going to creep in (it has already started) and tell her this or that is wrong with her.

Lisa said...

Simply beautiful. I think we could all use a reminder of that sometimes, thank you. One day she'll read these words and know how amazing her mom is, she'll know already but she'll see it again in these words.

Chaukie said...

What an amazing post. So beautifully said.

My kids are Korean and don't "match" us, so this something that is always on my mind. I see it coming out a little at a time with my 4 year old and pray that I have the right words at the right times. So far, so good, I hope. But the tougher stuff has me worried that I won't be prepared no matter how hard I try. So, thanks for so eloquently stating what I could not.

Magpie said...

Once upon a time, I saw a dance piece by Bill T Jones - at the end of which everyone was naked. Cast of many - 60? - all shapes, colors, sizes, ages - and everyone looked alike.

Rachel Cotterill said...

This is such a beautiful post... whatever happens as she grows up, I'm confident you'll handle it beautifully.

Audrey said...

I don't have anything to say that hasn't already been said. Well done. <3

Leah and Maya said...

oh how I LOVE this post. how do you teach them all of these things, I know I got stuck in it, the being skinny enough etc etc etc. Maya does compare eye color, and she has curly hair and she is three, she has friends and cousins that match her in differnt ways, so I like that she can see that everyone is differnt in everyway yet also the same.

Vodka Mom said...

that was amazing.

Yes, we all match.

Bridget said...

perfect. absolutely perfect.

Shannon- said...

You are beautiful.

Sprite's Keeper said...

Beautiful. Just beautiful. :-)

Mom24 said...

That's so, so beautiful. My darling baby is right around the corner from needing to hear this, and, I'm not proud of this, I really needed to hear this today. My darling girl's putting on weight faster and more than she should, her body's developing and changing faster than our society says it "should". Right now, she's not matching and she's beginning to sense it, beginning to hurt. I need to have the strength and wisdom to make sure she's healthy, and then reject society's demands.

Pamela said...

My good friend and neighbor adopted a little girl from China three years ago. Just the other night, that sweet girl sobbed for almost an hour because she wants her mama to be Chinese-American, too.

You are teaching your children well.

Issas Crazy World said...

Crying. I adore you. Have I told you that lately? This is a perfect post. I just love it. And? I love you.

You did very well my friend. Your answers to them were wonderful. You helped them understand, in the way they needed in the moment. The four year old way of understanding. The next time it comes up, just speak from your heart again. You can't protect any of them from hurts from time to time. Not your daughter, not you sons. Trust me, this I know. All you can do, is be there to explain from your heart when they need it.

Babe, remember something okay? You are her mother In the end that is what matters.

Tracey - Just Another Mommy Blog said...

Oh my word. I'm crying for the hope that someday, a 13 year old Ess will read this and know even a tiny fragment of the love you have for her.

Single PAP said...

beautiful

EatPlayLove said...

There will always be curiosity, but the most important thing is your constant love and understanding. It will fill your precious children with strength.

~Laura said...

So beautifully said and written. With a mother who thinks this way and is so communicative, your daughter will be more than fine. No worries...

AmazingGreis said...

I'm a little late to the party, but OMG what a spot on SUPER AWESOME beautiful post. You amaze me, friend. Your writing is superb!!! Your kids are lucky and will be glad to have so much to read and look back on as they get older.

(((hugs)))

Amy said...

"If you try to bleach or tan or sleep or puke or buy or exercise or read or drug your way to it, it will always elude you." So perfectly said!!

This is such a great, touching post. It is never, ever easy. I don't have this issue within my family, but my 20 year old daughter "matches" society's ideal - she's beautiful, with long shiny hair, blue eyes, flawless skin, tall, size 2. And it's been a challenge to make her understand - really know for sure - that her value is not there. It's lovely, but it is not the point at all. She's very smart, very funny, very kind, very generous. She has everything that is important, and it isn't what people see when they look at her passing by. It is a hard battle, because even when you match, you sometimes have to overcome parts of that too.

Michelle said...

Absolutely beautiful, Stacey. But at the same time, trust me, you aren't the only one dealing with matching and different. My kids do the same thing, as no one's eyes are the same, our hair is all different, etc. And different is different. And that's ok. Hopefully that message will sink in for all of them!

Bon said...

we are all human, all worthy.

i am still trying to teach myself this, and if i teach one thing to my kids, i hope it's this, just like you said it.

mam said...

You wrote the words for a future Ess, but I thank you on behalf of a future Lucy, who will be needing them sooner than I would wish on her or anyone.

Andrea's Sweet Life said...

So very well said, as always.

I read this post yesterday on my phone, so I wasn't able to comment - and then I dreamt about it last night!

I dreamt I was back at work at the preschool, and my curriculum was to have the kids separate into groups of who was the same and who was different... kind of like "one of these things is not like the others". I was so angry~ I didn't want to do the activity because, GAH!!!!
Anyway, so thanks for the dreams, lovely lady : )

Jeanne said...

Bu the same token, I worry about my grandkids, who may someday want to know who their father is, and he's just a coded record in a sperm bank somewhere. Not Harper so much, but Phinn seems to have inherited a bit of drama queen from his mom (and, okay, his grandma) and I can see this becoming a huge issue when he's an adolescent.

Or, maybe I'll just relax and enjoy the fact that he'll soon be 3 and let the future take care of itself, just for tonight.

T &amp; T Livesay said...

Love this post ... so many of the same conversations replayed. My Haitian son saw brown eggs at the store and exclaimed "These eggs are BROWN on the outside like me!" He added, "but inside they are the same just like a white shell egg."

Yep. :)

Heather said...

Lovely. Really lovely.

bernthis said...

oh boy, this is a tough one to be sure. My daughter says that kids that are like her are peach colored. She sees the differences but only as an observation, nothing more. I pray to keep her from those same thoughts of jealousy. I promise to always remind her, you don't know what goes on behind closed doors, so don't envy people, it's a waste of energy

SharonK said...

Very well explained to your children and the others in the group. I will keep this in mind as the questions arise in our household.

Having just taken in 2 pre-adoptive toddlers I am dealing with the opposite - oddly enough they both look just like me and my husband and my biological 13 year old doesn't. My 13 yr old has my features but her olive complexion and dark hair is very much her bio father's.

However, being 13, she is quick to point out that the kids would look nothing like me if I went back to my natural haircolor...

Debbie said...

What a beautiful post. We have these same concerns in my extended family.

Ayana said...

I’m not an adoptive parent so I know my situation is not really parallel, but this story hit a nerve with me. I’m black American and brown-skinned. My husband is Puerto Rican and has skin the color of a Pecan Sandie. We have two girls, a four-year-old who’s about a shade lighter than I am, and a one-year-old who’s about shade lighter than he is (genetics are weird...). The oldest has curly hair like mine, and the youngest's hair is straighter, like her father’s. They’re full-blooded genetic sisters, but they still don’t “match”. And my oldest, who is four, has started saying that she is “brown” like me and that her sister is “white” like Papi. She doesn’t assign any value to these categories. Yet. I worry myself sick at night that one day she will. So this is hard stuff to deal with in lots of different kinds of families. Good for you for being conscious of the issues and not afraid to address them directly with the kids. Yes, we're all different and we all match. But in your family, Ess is more different. At least, the outside world will perceive her to be. I wish you all the luck in the world as you work to ensure that she never views that difference as a deficiency.

Heather said...

(((hugs))) to you & her.

beautiful.

Kate Coveny Hood said...

This is one of your best posts ever. Making a mental note to submit it for the BlogHer community keynote. Now I just have to figure out how...

Jill said...

I find it so interesting to hear how kids compare themselves ... to each other, to their families, to their friends.

My kids are all varying shades of "white" and it amazes me how they've labeled each other... darky dark, lighty light, and whitey white - which is actually how they decide who gets the sunblock first when going out.

Casey said...

Gah, what a tough one. You nicely diffused the situation and I know that having you as her mom, she's going to grow up with the confidence she needs to not let things like that get to her. And she is beautiful, you all are.

Connie Weiss said...

Have I told you lately that I love you?

gnome517 said...

2quick things:
have you ever read the book "we are all alike, we are all differnt"? illustrates this point beautifully.
also, HOW DO YOU DO HER HAIR???? I have an AA foster daughter and I need help. can you point me in some direction? thanks :)
Naomi

Boy Crazy said...

I really admire the way you handled their questions and what you are striving to teach your kids. I hope I can do as well as my kids start forming their questions about race and color and matching and differences.

Haitian-American Family of Three said...

I worry about my kiddo and these conversations. Its hard and I am so glad that other mamas are writing about this experience too. Thanks for blogging!